MCNEILL, JOHN. Royal Ontario Museum, Toronto, and Royal Botanic Garden, Edinburgh, EH3 5LR, Scotland, UK. - Botanical nomenclature: on the threshold of major change?
The binomial system of botanical nomenclature has existed for almost
250 years, the principle of a taxon having a single correct name
determined on the basis of priority of publication was formalized
almost 150 years ago, and the type method for the application of
scientific names of plants has had international acceptance for almost
75 years. In this historic time-frame, do the next 50 years hold any
prospect of change, and indeed is any change possible or even
desirable? The requirement of botanical nomenclature to provide a
stable, unambiguous reference system for plant information implies an
inherent conservatism of rules and procedures – even the smallest
change to the Code, however beneficial it may be in general, is
virtually certain to have some destabilizing effect. Despite this
truism, it is suggested that the next few years will see quite major
change. Bionomenclature provides the mechanism for communication about
the elements of taxonomy and for those who perceive these solely, or
even primarily, in terms of phyletic lineages, a more or less
revolutionary phyletic nomenclature is probably indicated. But when
the elements of taxonomy seek to reflect the greatest information on
patterns of biodiversity, bionomenclature will continue to communicate
the general information content of taxa effectively, only if it
evolves to take fuller advantage of the opportunities of the
electronic age. The historical tendency to improve the rules of
nomenclature by continuous "tinkering" with the Code
needs to give way to a recognition that stability and simplicity are
key requirements of users of names (amongst whom professional
biologists are a relatively small minority), and that web access to
authoritative lists will generally be their preferred approach to
answering the nomenclatural questions that arise in their study and
use of plants, animals and micro-organisms.
Key words: bionomenclature, communication, information, International Code of Botanical Nomenclature, nomenclature, taxonomy